Poland's Supreme Court issued a resolution on Wednesday opposing the government's stance on the Constitutional Tribunal and backing the position of President Karol Nawrocki, Notes from Poland reported.
The resolution was issued in response to questions about whether Constitutional Tribunal rulings are valid, according to the facts of the case.
The Supreme Court ruled that Constitutional Tribunal rulings count only if issued by judges sworn in by the president, and that they take effect even if unpublished.
It said a valid tribunal ruling requires judges who took an oath before the president, in his presence, after parliament elected them.
Nawrocki has declined to swear in five Constitutional Tribunal judges, while the government has declined to publish 85 earlier tribunal rulings.
The parliamentary majority this year selected eight new Constitutional Tribunal judges, who would now hold a majority on the 15-seat tribunal. Nawrocki has refused to receive the oaths of five of those judges, citing concerns about how they were appointed or their qualifications.
Instead, those five judges organised swearing-in ceremonies before a notary, then sent their oaths on to the presidential chancellery, which they argue allows them to take their seats. That view is rejected by Nawrocki and the tribunal's chief justice Bogdan Święczkowski, who insist a judge cannot take up a seat on the court until the president has received the oath in person.
Since March 2024, Prime Minister Donald Tusk's coalition government has refused to publish all 85 tribunal rulings issued in that period. The government says three judges were unlawfully appointed to the tribunal under the former Law and Justice government, and argues tribunal rulings take force only when published in the Journal of Laws, as the former PiS government also argued in 2016.
Supreme Court judge Aleksander Stępkowski said executive failures to publish cannot affect the binding force of valid tribunal rulings, the Dziennik Gazeta Prawna daily quoted him as saying.
The Supreme Court resolution's own validity is contested because judges appointed via the overhauled National Council of the Judiciary issued it. Waldemar Żurek, the justice minister, stated that a ruling counts as non-existent if it involved even a single person appointed after 2017 via the politicised National Council of the Judiciary.



