Judges backed by the government who took over Poland's Constitutional Tribunal announced that chief justice Bogdan Święczkowski has lost his immunity to face criminal charges, according to Notes from Poland. The tribunal's website statement on Wednesday evening said motions by prosecutor general Waldemar Żurek to strip Święczkowski and deputy head Bartłomiej Sochański of immunity were approved.
The decision was made by the group of eight judges who took control of the tribunal on 30 October while riot police held back protesters outside. All eight were picked by the government's parliamentary majority this year, but President Karol Nawrocki has refused to swear in five of them.
After the takeover, the eight declared Święczkowski and Sochański suspended for failing their duties and began disciplinary proceedings, with hearings due later this week.
Żurek, who is both justice minister and prosecutor general, filed several requests to strip the pair's immunity for criminal charges; those were the ones approved.
Prosecutors want to charge Święczkowski with abuse of power and dereliction of duty over refusing to seat five judges chosen by parliament this year. Sochański faces the same accusations.
Święczkowski's argument is that Polish law obliges those judges to swear an oath before the president first, and they have not done so, so he cannot admit them. Prosecutors allege Święczkowski used violence against the five judges to physically stop them entering the judges' chambers at the tribunal.
According to prosecutors, while serving as national prosecutor under the previous PiS government he misused his powers by using surveillance material without authorisation. Prosecutors also accuse him of maliciously reassigning prosecutors to other locations as punishment without any legal basis.
The tribunal consented to the immunities being lifted, but did not agree that the pair could be detained and held in pretrial arrest. It also rejected two more Żurek requests to lift Święczkowski's immunity over other alleged claims, finding the motions had formal deficiencies.
Święczkowski immediately rejected the decisions as lacking legal validity and calls the eight judges usurpers. He calls the takeover an illegal coup and says decisions by the new judges are invalid.
The European Court of Human Rights said yesterday it refused Święczkowski's request for an emergency order suspending all proceedings against him at the tribunal. The court refused an interim measure sought by Święczkowski and Sochański to suspend all proceedings against them, finding they had not shown imminent risk of irreparable harm.
The ECHR said the applicants had failed to show an imminent risk of irreparable harm to the core of their rights. This contrasts with a May ECHR order that the five unsworn judges be admitted to the tribunal, which Święczkowski ignored, arguing the court lacked authority to issue it.
Święczkowski is still regarded by President Nawrocki as the tribunal's chief justice, and the president has condemned the takeover of the court by government-backed judges.
Supreme Court chief justice Zbigniew Kapiński backed Święczkowski and Nawrocki, telling RMF on Wednesday morning that decisions by the eight judges have no legal force. Kapiński's own position is disputed; he was appointed under PiS via a judicial body that European and Polish court rulings deemed illegitimate, according to Notes from Poland.
On Monday the central bank, whose governor is a longstanding associate of PiS leader Jarosław Kaczyński, suspended all outgoing payments from the tribunal's accounts amid uncertainty over who legitimately controls the court.



