Europe Dispatch Sunday, 22 November 2026
Europe Dispatch

Business·European Union

Schnabel says Europe's missing ingredient is scale, not talent or ideas

European Central Bank board member Isabel Schnabel said Europe's problem is scale rather than talent, and backed a 28th regime giving firms seamless access to the whole European market.

Portrait of economist Isabel Schnabel
Portrait of economist Isabel Schnabel Foto: Gregor Fischer / CC BY 2.0 / via Wikimedia Commons
Share on X WhatsApp

Isabel Schnabel has said the idea that Europe is declining is misleading despite its simplicity, according to the European Central Bank.

Martin Zielke and Isabel Schnabel at a banking panel 2017
Martin Zielke and Isabel Schnabel at a banking panel 2017 Foto: Gregor Fischer / CC BY 2.0 / via Wikimedia Commons

Schnabel argued that Europe's key missing ingredient is scale, not talent, ideas or research.

She said a 28th regime would give firms seamless access to the whole European market.

Schnabel said such a regime could let Europe compete as one economy and build a Made in Europe brand.

Banking panel with Merz, Zielke, Schnabel and Boekhout
Banking panel with Merz, Zielke, Schnabel and Boekhout Foto: Gregor Fischer / CC BY 2.0 / via Wikimedia Commons

A baby born in Spain or Italy is expected to live five years longer than one born in the US.

Schnabel said euro area GDP per capita, adjusted for cost of living, ranks below other advanced economies.

She said US employees work around 40 more days per year on average than euro area employees.

Schnabel said that if Europeans worked US hours, euro area real GDP per capita would be 21% higher.

She said that counterfactual would close about two-thirds of the real income gap with the US.

In the US, the top 10% of earners take around 37% of national income after taxes, Schnabel said, while in the euro area the top 10% share is significantly lower, around 27% on average.

Schnabel said the typical American lives in a USD 45,000 economy, not a USD 67,000 one, and that real GDP per capita grew largely in step in the median US state and median euro area country.

She said weak euro area productivity growth threatens Europe's advantages and is rightly a policy priority.

According to the European Commission, potential growth in Spain, Portugal and Greece is projected to be measurably above the euro area average, Schnabel said.

Schnabel said France's deficit reduction has stalled due to political resistance, and that Austria spent both 2023 and 2024 in recession and managed only modest growth in 2025.

She said Germany's real GDP per capita fell by 0.5% from 2019 to 2024, and that Germany grew just 1.4% annually on average between 1999 and 2019, less than most advanced economies.

Schnabel said Germany's problem is weak domestic demand, not a competitiveness collapse, making its export model unviable, and that since 1999 German real private consumption grew under 1% per year on average as early-2000s reforms suppressed real wages.

European Commission estimates suggest Germany's expected current account surplus is about 1.2% of GDP, a fraction of the current level, she said.

Earlier coverage

Our earlier stories about the people and organisations in this one.

  1. ECB's Schnabel says central banks should favour tools allowing quick policy shifts

    Isabel Schnabel said central banks should favour tools that let them adjust policy quickly, warning that asset purchases keep easing long after buying ends.

  2. ECB survey finds more euro area firms reporting higher bank loan rates

    A net 46% of euro area firms reported a further rise in bank loan interest rates in the 40th SAFE round, the European Central Bank said, with loan availability falling in Q3 2026.

  3. ECB's Elderson says nature protection is investment as biodiversity loss poses economic risk

    European Central Bank board member Frank Elderson said the world must act on nature loss, citing estimates that up to half of world GDP depends on biodiversity and ecosystem services.

  4. ECB's Elderson says climate risks now affect prices as well as growth

    European Central Bank board member Frank Elderson said climate and nature risks fall within the ECB's mandate because they affect prices as well as growth, after a record-hot summer in Western Europe.